CPA Firm Staffing Shortage: Hire, Outsource or Both?
By Sunny Patel, CA5 min read
Your best senior just gave notice, three job postings have been open since August, and the extension pile is already growing. A CPA firm staffing shortage is not a hiring problem you can fix in one quarter, and it is not only a headcount problem either. It is a capacity problem with several possible answers.
This post compares the three realistic ones, hiring, outsourcing, and a mix of both, so you can match the fix to the kind of gap you actually have.
In this post
- How big the shortage is, and where the numbers come from
- Option 1: Hire more staff
- Option 2: Outsource the work
- Option 3: A blended model
- A simple way to decide
- Frequently asked questions
- The short version
How big is the CPA firm staffing shortage?
Two sources are worth knowing. The AICPA’s 2025 Trends report, released in October 2025, found that 40,817 students earned an accounting bachelor’s degree in the 2023-24 academic year, down 3.3% from the year before, and that master’s degrees in accounting and taxation fell about 15% to 14,335. New CPA Exam candidates surged to 42,626 in 2023, the year before the exam changed, then fell to 28,082 in 2024 (AICPA & CIMA). The same report notes that the decline is slowing and that accounting enrollment grew in the 2024-25 school year, so the pipeline may be starting to recover.
On the firm side, the AICPA’s 2024 PCPS CPA Firm Top Issues Survey, with 667 respondents, found that finding qualified staff was the top issue for every category of firm except sole practitioners. Retaining staff ranked second for firms with 11 or more professionals (AICPA & CIMA).
Even if enrollment recovers, it takes years for new graduates to become the experienced seniors and reviewers firms are short of. For planning, assume you will keep competing for the same experienced people. Check the latest AICPA releases before you quote these figures in a client or board setting.
Option 1: Hire more staff
Hiring builds a team that knows your clients, your culture and your software. It is the right answer for roles that need client contact, judgment and long-term development, such as managers and reviewers.
The trade-offs are timing and fixed cost. A hire takes time to find, onboard and train, and the cost stays after busy season ends. If your gap is a seasonal spike, a permanent salary is an expensive way to cover a few months.
Hiring fits best when the work needs to sit close to the client and the demand is steady all year.
Option 2: Outsource the work
Outsourcing moves defined, repeatable work, such as bookkeeping, tax return preparation and write-up, to a team outside your firm. Capacity can come online faster than a hire, and it flexes up and down with your calendar.
The trade-offs are control and risk. You need written scope, a review process, data protection, and the right client consent for tax work sent offshore. Consent and disclosure rules are covered in our post on IRC §7216 in plain English. Choosing the right provider is covered in our 12-point checklist for choosing an offshore accounting partner.
Outsourcing fits best when the work is repeatable, volume swings by season, and your reviewers can set clear standards. You can see what we cover on our bookkeeping and accounting and tax preparation support pages.
Option 3: A blended model
Many firms end up here, because the two options solve different problems. Hire for the roles that carry client relationships and review. Outsource the preparation and processing work that sits underneath them. Your hires then spend their hours on judgment instead of data entry, which also helps retention, since people tend to stay where the work is more interesting.
A blended model needs a clear line between what stays in-house and what goes out, and a review process that holds up under volume. We cover that in offshore accounting quality control and in adding busy-season capacity without hiring. To start the outsourced side with one small workstream, see how to onboard an offshore team in 30 days.
A simple way to decide
Answer four questions about the gap you have right now.
| Question | Leans toward hiring | Leans toward outsourcing |
|---|---|---|
| Is the demand steady or seasonal? | Steady all year | Seasonal or uneven |
| Is the work client-facing or back-office? | Client-facing, judgment-heavy | Repeatable, process-driven |
| How fast do you need capacity? | You can wait a few months | You need it this season |
| Can your reviewers set written standards? | Review is informal | Review is documented |
If most answers sit in one column, start there. If they split, the blended model is probably your answer. Whichever way you go, begin with one defined workstream, measure review notes and rework for a month, and then expand. For how that handoff works in practice, see how we work, and for what data protection looks like, see our security page.
Frequently asked questions
What is causing the CPA firm staffing shortage?
The AICPA’s 2025 Trends report shows fewer accounting degrees awarded and fewer new CPA Exam candidates, while its 2024 firm survey shows firms ranking staff recruitment and retention as a top concern.
Is outsourcing cheaper than hiring?
It depends on the work, volume and provider, so compare quotes against your fully loaded cost per hour, including recruiting, training and idle time. See our pricing page for how we structure engagements. We do not quote an industry-wide savings figure because we have not found a reliable, sourced one.
Will outsourcing hurt client relationships?
Not when client contact stays with your team and outsourced staff handle back-office preparation. Clients deal with the same people they always have. What changes is how much of your team’s time goes to production work.
How long does it take to add outsourced capacity?
Setup depends on scope, tools access and consent paperwork. A small, defined pilot is usually the fastest way to start, and it lets you test quality before committing more volume.
Should I hire and outsource at the same time?
Often yes. Hiring covers the senior and client-facing roles; outsourcing covers repeatable preparation. The two work together as long as roles and review points are clear.
The short version
A CPA firm staffing shortage has more than one fix. Hire for client-facing and review roles that need to stay close to your firm. Outsource repeatable preparation work that swings with the season. Most firms need both, started with one small, measurable workstream.
This post is general information, not legal or tax advice. Confirm your own obligations with qualified counsel.